Delica and JDE litigating over aluminum coffee capsules

Reading time: 4 minutes

Case No. O2020_002 | Judgment of 21 December 2021

DISCLOSURE NOTICE: Hepp Wenger Ryffel was involved in this matter on behalf of Delica AG.
Delica logo

The plaintiff Delica had initiated nullity proceedings against Douwe Egbert’s CH 711 079 B1 on 2 June 2020; see Swissreg for bibliographic details.

CH 079 is part of a complex patent family. Corresponding to CH 079, the patent family comprises DE 20 2016 106 171 U1 (see the DPMA Register and file wrapper for further information), i.e. a utility model that was split off from a patent application (DE 10 2016 006 034 A1) which itself has meanwhile been been rejected in 2018 (cf. DPMA Register / file wrapper).

It is noted in ¶16 of the judgment that Douwe Egberts had initiated infringement proceedings 21 O 12764/19 in Munich, which are currently stayed in view of the cancellation proceedings; cf. order of 5 August 2020.

Coffee capsule

Claim 1 of CH 079 is pretty lengthy. In a nutshell, it’s about a coffee capsule with an aluminum capsule body and an aluminum cover, wherein the dispute was mainly about a specific arrangement of a sealing element in the flange of the capsule. Further independent claims pertain to a corresponding system and use of said capsule.

DE logo

About half of the judgment is dealing with the procedural history and a recitation of the various requests for maintenance of CH 079 in limited form; DE did not defend CH 079 as granted anymore. Yet further 12 pages of the judgment are spent on claim construction. The latter paved the way for a straight-forward assessment of patentability on the merits: The judgment holds that the subject-matter of all requests on file is anticipated by WO 2014 / 184 652 A1. Accordingly, CH 079 has been revoked and the further novelty attacks based on WO 2014 / 184 653 A1, WO 2014 / 198 474 A1, WO 2014 / 184 651 A1, EP 1 700 548 A1 and WO 2013 / 120 997 A1 did not need to be addressed.

The judgment is not yet final / can still be appealed to the Supreme Court.

Reported by Martin WILMING

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Case No. O2020_002 | Judgment of 21 December 2021

Delica AG
./.
Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V.

Panel of Judges:

    • Dr. Mark SCHWEIZER
    • André WERNER
    • Kurt STOCKER

Judge-rapporteur:

    • André WERNER

Court Clerk:

    • Susanne ANDERHALDEN

Representative(s) of Plaintiff:

Representative(s) of Defendant:

    • Andrea MONDINI (TIMES)
    • Dr. Theodore CHOI (SBMP), assisting in patent matters
    • Christoph FRAEFEL (SBMP), assisting in patent matters

DECISION IN FULL

PATENT IN SUIT

BE ON THE KNOW

Enter your name and email address below to get notified of new posts by email.